I make a point to completely turn off my phone when I enter a cinema. Not simply on silent mode – all the way off. I mention this not from a place of judgment, or in the hope that the spirit of Billy Wilder will return to offer approval. I consider it as a simple minor indulgences: for at least an hour and a half, I am entirely unreachable. I keep my phone deactivated for the duration of the scroll as well. It seems luxurious to remain seated as other patrons slowly filter out, lit only by the closing titles.
And, more and more, by the glow of the cataloguing app.
Over millions of people engage with Letterboxd, a film-cataloguing application. In the vein of A24, it has evolved into industry shorthand for a particular kind of influencer who champions latest films and delights in rediscovering vintage films. Patrons score and write about films, and the most insightful or most illuminating commentaries rise to prominence, encouraging film lovers to put in effort.
"If I don't articulate my impressions immediately after the credits roll, my critiques are significantly less lucid and well-put," noted a student.
During a recent visit to the cinema, the credits had barely started before the patron ahead of me commenced writing his review. A few seats over, a couple remained seated, focused on their screens, noting their personal reactions.
The legendary artist David Lynch shared some guidance: record every spark of inspiration the precise instant it occurs to you. Failing to do so, it could slip your mind, and, in his words: "If you forget a good idea, you want to commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to budding directors, the same principle fits the Letterboxd experience.
Josh Stern, a young student in New York, invariably composes his critiques before leaving the auditorium.
"Should I fail to articulate my impressions promptly after the credits roll, my write-ups are much less lucid and well-put," he said. "It takes a bit. I'm pretty slow, and my partner doesn't like it."
He visits the movies frequently – 182 times in a single year – and is on a first-name basis with the ushers, who occasionally have to ask him to leave so they can begin cleaning the theater. He thinks it acceptable to take advantage of the end credits: "When you purchase a cinema ticket, the credits constitute a portion of the feature."
The platform's most passionate users credit the platform with reinvigorating interest around a struggling cinema sector, where fewer films are made and work is scarce. (Letterboxd also has the kind of audience data brands desire – its biggest group of users is between 18 and 24, followed by 25 to 35.)
Excitement begets further excitement; eagerly anticipated movies see a surge of engagement on Letterboxd immediately after the first showings. The highest-rated review of a divisive adaptation – "the author succumbed centuries ago yet this version is still the greatest injustice that has ever happened to her" – has amassed more than 50,000 hearts. A separate recent film inspired this contrast to a pop star's concert film: "that other tour film discovered deceased."
"It feels like a habit," said a marketing professional, a thirty-three-year-old resident who works in marketing. He also prefers to write reviews in the closing scroll. "Reflecting on what you just experienced, right after you watched it, aids the artistic experience. It clarifies the key messages of a film. If it produces a sense of contentment, that's not necessarily something you retain hours later."
This user feels most compelled to review a film if it was very good – or exceptionally bad. Case in point: he recently sat through a sci-fi project. "I found myself so disappointed by how utterly terrible it was, that I was excited to take out my phone and award it a lowest possible score," he said. (This reviewer is a tougher reviewer than established reviewers, who awarded the film three stars, calling it "ingenious and watchable fare.")
A social media manager, a 28-year-old professional who is in social media, watched an acclaimed movie at a cinema on the Upper West Side and stayed to write the review ("I gave it five stars"). He has clocked poorer etiquette: people pulling out their phones to log the movie they are currently watching. "That action irritates me," he commented.
One of the movie industry's most persistent urban legends recounts a screening of an early motion picture that depicted a train pulling into a station. The medium was in its earliest days and – in line with this debunked anecdote – the shot of a locomotive moving right toward the camera terrified the crowd so much that people ran away in terror.
Many decades later, audience behavior remains just as questionable. Apparently, few people remember how to behave in a theater any more, notably when the lights dim: patrons take pictures of the screen, smuggle in strong-smelling food, and, as occurred during a cultural moment, sometimes engage in outright brawls.
Some individuals have turned to social media to debate the appropriateness of "Letterboxding" during the end sequence. When one social media user